Potluck sign-ups, minus the dated tooling
Perfect Potluck does one thing. MySignMeUp handles your potluck just as easily — with a clean, mobile-first signup page — then does volunteer shifts, snack rotations, and class slots too.
The short version
Stay on Perfect Potluck if you are coordinating meals for one family after a birth, surgery or bereavement. It is free, it has no paid tier, and it is built for exactly that. Switch to MySignMeUp when the list stops being meals — shifts, supplies, classroom helpers, appointment slots — or when you want reminders, waitlists that auto-promote, and a roster you can export.
Last updated . Perfect Potluck pricing was read off their own pricing page that day.
What Perfect Potluck costs
- Price
- Free. Perfect Potluck publishes no paid tier and no pricing page.
- Published limits
- None stated on the site.
- Participant account
- Not required. Participants reach a meal schedule by link, or by the coordinator's last name and a password.
- Ads
- Not mentioned anywhere on the site.
Verified 22 September 2026. Plans change — confirm current terms with Perfect Potluck before buying.
MySignMeUp vs. Perfect Potluck
A quick, honest comparison of what you get out of the box.
| Feature | MySignMeUp | Perfect Potluck |
|---|---|---|
| Potluck dish coordination | Yes | Yes |
| Capacity limits per dish | Yes | Limited |
| Mobile-first signup page | Yes | No |
| Modern, ad-free interface | Yes | No |
| Ready-made templates | Yes | No |
| Works beyond potlucks (volunteers, shifts, classes) | Yes | No |
| Waitlists with auto-promote | Yes | No |
| Automatic email reminders | Pro | Limited |
| No account needed to sign up | Yes | Yes |
Comparison based on publicly available Perfect Potluck plan information. Perfect Potluck is a trademark of its respective owner; MySignMeUp is not affiliated with or endorsed by it.
Why organizers switch
Built for potlucks and everything else
Use one tool for the potluck, the volunteer day, and the snack schedule — instead of a different site for each.
A signup page people actually enjoy
Clean, modern, and mobile-first. No clutter, no dated forms, no ads — just tap a dish and you're done.
Set quantities and stop duplicates
Cap how many of each dish you need, so you don't end up with five desserts and no main.
Reminders so dishes actually show up
Automatic email reminders go out before the event, so fewer people forget what they signed up to bring.
When to stay on Perfect Potluck
For a meal train, Perfect Potluck is genuinely better than we are, and it costs nothing. It knows what a meal train is: dates rather than slots, dietary notes, a delivery time per day, and the assumption that the family receiving the meals should not have to administer anything. We make you build that out of a generic sheet.
It has also been running since 2010 and publishes no paid tier, so there is no upsell waiting for you at the point where your list gets popular. If meals are the whole job, use it and ignore the rest of this page.
Switching questions
Can MySignMeUp organize a potluck like Perfect Potluck?
Yes — there's a ready-made potluck template with slots for appetizers, mains, sides, desserts, and drinks, plus capacity caps and reminders.
Can I use it for things other than potlucks?
Absolutely. The same tool handles volunteer shifts, snack rotations, class sign-ups, conference slots, and more.
Do guests need an account to sign up?
No. They open the link, claim a dish, and add their name — no account required.
Is MySignMeUp free?
Yes. Free includes unlimited sheets, up to 10 slots each, 25 sign-ups per month, shareable links, and an ad-free signup page. Email reminders and CSV export come with Pro.